A heater that keeps heating after the water reaches the temperature you set is a safety problem, not a minor annoyance. This guide covers what to do first, based on the manufacturer’s own instructions, and when to stop using the heater.

Quick answer: If the heater keeps heating after the water has passed the temperature you set, treat it as faulty. Unplug it, check the real water temperature with a separate thermometer, and rule out simple causes such as the set point or an outside heat source. If the water still runs warm, stop using the heater and replace it or contact the manufacturer.
Safety first: Unplug the heater, and disconnect other tank equipment from the mains, before you put your hands in the water. The heater is very hot during and right after use, so don’t touch its heating zone.
This is based on the safety instructions in Eheim’s operating manual for its thermocontrole heaters (models 3631 to 3640). Other brands may differ, so check your own manual.
Signs your aquarium heater is stuck on
- A separate thermometer reads well above the temperature you set, even after the heater has had time to settle.
- The heater’s indicator light stays on while the water is above your setting. On Eheim thermocontrole heaters, the light is red while heating and turns green once the set temperature is reached.
If you see either sign, follow the steps below.
What to do first: a 5-step checklist

Step 1: Unplug it and let it cool in the water
Take the plug out of the outlet. Eheim says an unplugged heater should stay in the water for at least 30 minutes to cool before you remove it. If it was pulled out while running, don’t put it back in the water. Unplug it and let it cool on a heat-resistant surface for at least one hour.
Step 2: Check the real water temperature
Use a separate thermometer, not the heater’s dial or light. Eheim’s manual tells owners to check the water temperature at regular intervals, and it lists an accuracy of about 0.5°C (1.0°F) for its thermocontrole range. A reading far above your setting after the heater has had time to settle goes beyond that margin and points to a fault. Other brands list different figures, so check your manual.
Also look at the control light. On the Eheim thermocontrole, a light that stays red while your thermometer reads above the setting is worth reporting to the manufacturer.
Step 3: Rule out simple causes
- The set point. Compare the dial or ring to your thermometer reading.
- Outside heat. Sunlight, a hot room or other equipment near the tank can add warmth.
- Your thermometer. If you have a second one, use it to confirm the reading.
Step 4: Don’t try to repair or adjust it
Eheim says repairs must be carried out by an Eheim service centre, that you should only do the work the manual describes, and that you should never make technical modifications. Its guarantee does not include opening the device. The manual doesn’t describe a user fix for a heater that won’t switch off. Some other heater lines have a calibration dial, so follow only your own heater’s manual.
Step 5: Stop using it and replace it or contact the manufacturer
Eheim’s safety instructions say not to operate an appliance that is malfunctioning. For this heater series the guarantee is 3 years, but it does not include glass damage, improper use or opening the appliance. Keep your receipt and model number when you contact the maker.
Quick reference: what you see and what to do
| What you see | What it may mean | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| A thermometer well above your setting and the heater light still on | A possible heater fault | Unplug it, follow the steps above and stop using the heater |
| A thermometer above your setting but the light shows the heater has reached temperature | A set point, outside heat or thermometer problem | Check the setting, look for outside heat and confirm with a second thermometer |
| A cracked glass body or damaged cord | The heater is not safe to use | Unplug it, don’t use it again and contact the manufacturer |
How to prevent a repeat
- Keep a separate thermometer in the tank so you always have a second reading.
- Know what your heater’s protection covers. Eheim’s thermal circuit breaker switches the heater off if it runs outside the water or the water level is too low, and it switches back on after cooling. The manual describes it for that situation, not for a thermostat fault.
- Be careful with timers and controllers. Eheim’s manual says this heater may not be operated with an additional timer or an additional control system. Check your own heater’s manual before adding either.
- Use a residual current protective device. Eheim recommends protecting all electrical aquarium appliances with a device rated for 30 mA or less.
- Check the glass and cord before use. Make sure the glass body isn’t broken or cracked. The cord can’t be replaced, so a damaged cord means the heater must be scrapped.
Frequently asked questions
Can I leave a stuck-on heater plugged in and keep an eye on it?
No. Eheim’s safety instructions say not to operate an appliance that is malfunctioning. Unplug it, check the water temperature with a separate thermometer, and replace the heater or contact the manufacturer.
Should I pull the heater out of the tank right away?
Not straight away. Eheim says to unplug it and leave it in the water for at least 30 minutes to cool before removing it. If it was removed while running, don’t put it back in the water. Let it cool on a heat-resistant surface for at least one hour.
How accurate should an aquarium heater be?
Eheim lists about 0.5°C (1.0°F) for its thermocontrole heaters, across a 20 to 32°C (68 to 90°F) range. Other brands list different figures, so check the manual for your model.
Can I recalibrate or repair a stuck heater myself?
Eheim says repairs must be done by an Eheim service centre and that you shouldn’t modify the heater. Its guarantee does not include opening the appliance. Some other heater lines have a calibration dial, so follow only your own heater’s manual.
Does the built-in thermal cutoff protect against a stuck heater?
In Eheim’s manual, the thermal circuit breaker is described for running without water or with a very low water level, and the heater restarts after cooling. It isn’t described as protection against the water getting too warm because of a thermostat fault, so don’t rely on it for that.
What should I do about my fish?
This page covers the heater, not your fish. If the tank has been very warm and fish look distressed, contact a local aquarium store or an aquatic vet right away.
What this page doesn’t cover
This page covers heater equipment only. It doesn’t give fish-health, medication or water-chemistry advice, and it doesn’t describe electrical repair.
Sources and last verified
- Eheim, operating manual for the adjustable aquarium heater thermocontrole 25 to 400 (official PDF): eheim.com
Last verified: November 19, 2026, against the English operating manual and the US safety instructions in that PDF.
